14 August 2010

Things

There are so many things a kid can’t discuss in therapy. She tells him ”this is a safe place to share”, ”you can talk to me about anything” and ”everything we talk about in this room stays between us”, but it’s all lies. Honesty puts you ”at risk”, he learned this a long time ago. You’re left with the not-so-important things. ”How’s school?” Fine. ”Are you getting enough sleep?” I guess. ”Did you do anything fun over the weekend?” Not really. ”You look happy/sad/angry/bored today.” Sometimes she’ll ask him to fill out a form where you rate your feelings on a scale from 1-10. He never strays too far from what’s considered normal. Not too high, not too low, but somewhere in the middle. Indifference is good. A blank expression is even better. Don’t cross your arms, don’t clench your fists. Don’t cross your legs, it’s feminine. Don’t sit with your legs too wide apart, it’s threatening. Long sleeves, even though it’s 85 degrees outside. If pushed he’ll say, ”I miss my dog”. I miss. Me. She once asked ”Do you think you’ll grow up to be a perp? Is this something you worry about?” It made him wonder if she’d ask a girl the same thing. With boys it’s automatic. Only boys grow up to be perpetrators, abusers, rapists, wife beaters, sadists. It was a question made to rattle him, shake him up, make him talk, but he hates her now. Men are inherently evil, we’re wired this way. There must be something wrong with our bodies, something wrong with our brains. There’s something wrong with me. The truth is he’s more worried about growing up to be like his mother, hopelessly stuck and powerless, unable to do a damn thing about anything. He wants to say, “I have something in common with her, we’re both scared of men”, but it sounds ridiculous, funny almost. What if she laughs at him? He can feel his face redden. The pain stays. It stays right here.

17 comments:

Sitting Behind Homeplate said...

I found that sometimes (for me) its best to find a true friend to talk to and share the things I can't share with a "professional". I know that isn't the regular route for professional help but maybe a friend can be more helpful.

Connie

Whimsy said...

Charlie, your writing is so powerful.
I wish I could say something clever, or helpful, but all I can do is send over Internet Hugs.

Internet Hugs can't do much, and I'm not sure if the thought even is a good idea, since I've never met you, but here's one anyway.

*hugs*

Also, your blog posts are quite possibly my favorite ones to read, and I'm subscribed to quite a few blogs.

~Whimsy

kittens not kids said...

no decent therapist is going to laugh at anything you say to them. unless, of course, you make a joke. that MAY get a smile. and if a therapist DOES laugh inappropriately, then it's time to find a new one.

I think I'd cry if a therapist asked me if I thought I'd grow up to be "a perp."

But it does feel unfair, doesn't it, that you're supposed to reveal ALL this stuff, all your crazy and insecurity and worry and fear, to someone and they don't have to share any of THEIRS with you?

But i can tell you this, and it comes partly from listening to my students' problems: there is all kinds of weird and crazy shit going on out there, with all kinds of people. It's not likely anything you (or anyone) says to their therapist is going to sound particularly wacky.
after all, it's therapy. it's where you GO if you have issues.

at the animal shelter where i volunteer, they have a program where kids who struggle with reading read out loud with a specially trained reading-buddy dog. The thinking is that the dog is a totally safe listener - they're trained, and they're NEVER going to laugh or make fun of you or yell at you if you make mistakes. I love this program very much. It sounds a little bit like maybe you could use a therapy dog to practice on, someone safe who you KNOW is listening, but is never going to laugh, or think you're weird, or wrong.
(this is both a metaphor and literal, I think. I think).

Anonymous said...

tough stuff ... sucks when we can't talk freely ... i like the internet for that but its very frustrating

Anonymous said...

im sick of reading about whiney rich boys

MartininBroda said...

@Anonymous: you have no clue, how wrong you are.

@Charlie sorry had some comp probs, will finish your belated birthday post this evening.

naturgesetz said...

"Honesty puts you 'at risk', he learned this a long time ago." The things is that he needs to unlearn some things he learned long ago — or at least not to universalize them. Lots of us do. There are many situations where honesty can put people at risk, but if therapy is to work, it requires being honest about what one is thinking. I know it's not easy, but I sincerely believe that the more he can speak about what's on his mind, the better he can handle it.

As you say, she asked that question in hopes of finally getting some honest, heartfelt reaction that would be worth talking about.

Look, I haven't read everything you've posted, and I don't know exactly what it was that led to his being in therapy, but if it's to do any good, he'll have to say something meaningful sometime. If he can't bring himself to talk about it, maybe you could print out some of the things you've posted here that might relate to what happened to him and let him show them to her.

Why won't he give the therapy a real chance? Is it because he wants the pain to stay? To stay right here? Is it safer, or better in some other way for him to hold onto it than to face life without it?

I'm here today because I saw on Martin's blog that you just had your birthday. I hope t was happy, and I hope you will have many happy birthdays to come.

kittens not kids said...

oh gosh! a birthday! a belated birthday post coming right up. I hope you had a good day and felt beloved and happy to be here.

I'm glad you were born and that you are the person you are; I'm glad I found you out here in the vast wilds of the internet.

Charlie said...

Connie, thanks for your suggestion. Talking to a friend works for me also, but I sometimes worry that if I lean on them too hard they'll break (or they'll get fed up with listening).

Thank you so much for the hug, Whimsy. ((Hugging you back)). I told one of my blog friends about your blog, he's a gay teen from Germany. Go say hello if you want. http://lunariosbook.blogspot.com/

Kittens, I love what you wrote about having a "therapy dog" to practice on. It sounds like a great program to be involved with. And thanks for the birthday wishes, I'm really glad I found you and your blog, too :)

goleftatthefork, thanks for stopping by my blog. Talking to people online does help in a big way.

Anon, whining is my speciality I'm afraid :) Feel free to stop reading.

Martin, thanks for the lovely birthday post :)

Naturgesetz, thanks for the insightful comment. You're right, and I think he knows that he needs to change and unlearn some things in order for it to work. Holding onto the pain feels safer in a lot of ways because it's familiar. As long as the pain stays inside, he's in complete control. If that makes sense. Thanks for the birthday wishes.

Sitting Behind Homeplate said...

Your welcome Charlie and I'm betting you will find the strong friend to lean on - just remember them when you have happy stuff too ;)

I completely understand the control issue. That one is hard to give up because what if you give it up and the same thing happens to you again! At some point you have to give it up because you lost the control of the issue you are trying to control.

Please keep writing - you are very talented.

Connie

Martin van Duijn said...

A good 17th, Charlie! Sorry about me following you twice, but Blogger is messing up, and it won't correct it.

Charlie said...

Thanks, Connie. Happy stuff is important too :)

Thank you, Martin. Nice to see you here. I'd follow your blog (if you have one), but I can't find a link on your profile.

Martin van Duijn said...

No blog yet... but I'll let you know when it will be online. Fixed the Blogger issue though.

Some strong and powerful writing in your most recent entry, it cuts through the soul.

Sitting Behind Homeplate said...

Just wondering how you are doing? School start yet?

Connie

Robert Guthrie said...

Hi Charlie - Three cheers that you're one of the strongest, most authentic voices in the blogosphere!

Charlie said...

I'm good thanks, Connie. School started a week ago.

Thanks so much for the nice compliment, Robert.

Lisa Nowak said...

It's all about trust, isn't it? If you feel you can trust a therapist, you can talk. But when you're a kid, you always have to worry about those in power over you. Even as an adult, it's hard to bare your soul, but at least you know that you have the power to walk out of the room without repercussions if things get too tough. All that said, sometimes it's worth the risk. Maybe not with this therapist, but someday with another.